Technical Requirements for Concrete in Compliance with European Standards

Technical Requirements for Concrete in Compliance with European Standards

This article presents several issues related to the draft standards concerning the classification of exposure environments, the use of mineral additives, the specification of technical requirements for various types of concrete, and conformity assessment. European standards aim for quality and efficiency, but there are differences compared to the current national standards in Vietnam. To effectively implement the draft standards on concrete technical requirements under the new direction, further research and the development of technical guidelines, along with regulatory provisions harmonized with the European system, are necessary.

1. Background

Despite its long-standing use and its status as the most common building material in Vietnam, many challenges remain in specifying, controlling, and evaluating the technical requirements for concrete. Typically, designers specify performance criteria to ensure load-bearing capacity and durability, while manufacturers and constructors are responsible for the quality of the concrete provided and its performance in the structure. Concrete is a material whose properties develop during construction, influenced by various factors, from raw materials to production technology and environmental conditions. Therefore, ensuring quality requires detailed, consistent regulations on classification, specification of requirements, materials, and the production process, as well as clearly defined responsibilities of all parties involved.

In Vietnam, since 1991, according to TCVN 5574:1991 [1], concrete has been classified based on three properties: compressive strength, tensile strength, and impermeability. These are the basic requirements that must be specified in the design. Subsequent standards, such as TCXDVN 356:2005, TCVN 5574:2012, and the most recent update TCVN 5574:2018 [2], expanded the classification to five properties: compressive strength, axial tensile strength, impermeability, bulk density, and pre-stress strength. Corrosion protection requirements for concrete and reinforced concrete structures are specified in TCVN 9346:2012 [3] and TCVN 12251:2018 [4]. Other specifications concerning workability and additional issues are outlined in TCVN 4453:1995 [5] and TCVN 9340:2012 [6], while strength assessment and concrete acceptance are covered in TCVN 4453:1995 and TCVN 10303:2014 [7]. Most of these standards were developed based on Soviet and Russian standards and tailored to Vietnamese conditions. However, due to the lack of regular reviews and updates, certain issues have arisen in their application.

To address these challenges, following the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 198/QD-TTg on February 9, 2018, which approved the project to complete the system of construction standards and technical regulations, the Ministry of Construction identified core standards for the construction industry and began drafting new standards following a new direction. Among these, the standards for designing concrete and reinforced concrete structures have been recognized as core standards, guided by the European standard EN 1992 (Eurocode 2). Consequently, related standards on concrete technical requirements, testing methods, and construction practices must also be drafted accordingly.

 

In Europe, the first standard for concrete technical requirements was published in 2000 under the code EN 206-1:2000. This standard was revised in 2013 to include issues related to self-compacting concrete, resulting in EN 206:2013. Subsequent updates were made in 2016 and 2021, with the latest version being EN 206:2013+A2:2021 [8]. The draft national technical requirements for concrete, currently being developed by the Institute of Building Science and Technology (IBST) under the Ministry of Construction, is based on this standard.

EN 206:2013+A2:2021 covers issues related to exposure environment classification, concrete classification based on properties, material requirements, concrete mix design, responsibilities and interactions between stakeholders, concrete production, and conformity assessment. The scope of this standard encompasses many existing standards in Vietnam. By unifying these aspects in a single standard, it simplifies and standardizes use, but some concepts and provisions may be unfamiliar to users in Vietnam. Additionally, even in European countries, supplementary guidelines are necessary for specific local conditions. Similar documents have not yet been developed for Vietnam.

This article aims to analyze several new concepts and content differences in the draft national standard on concrete technical requirements based on EN 206:2013+A2:2021, its feasibility, and proposals for applying it to Vietnamese conditions.

2. Exposure Environment

Concrete and reinforced concrete structures not only need to ensure load-bearing capacity but also must guarantee durability, maintaining operational performance throughout their intended lifespan. Therefore, environmental impacts must be considered at the outset of design and factored into the design calculations. Based on the chemical and physical characteristics and their corrosive effects on concrete, the exposure environment is categorized into six groups: 01 non-corrosive group, 03 groups with corrosion risk for reinforced concrete, and 02 groups with corrosion risk for plain concrete. Within each risk group, the environment is further classified into 3 or 4 different levels.

The non-corrosive environment (X0) for concrete includes all environments except those involving freeze-thaw, abrasion, and chemical corrosion, while for reinforced concrete, it refers to very dry conditions.

The group of environments with a corrosion risk due to carbonation consists of four levels: dry or permanently wet (XC1), wet, rarely dry (XC2), medium humidity (XC3), and cyclic wetting and drying (XC4).

The group of environments with a corrosion risk due to chlorides not from seawater consists of three levels: medium humidity (XD1), wet, rarely dry (XD2), and cyclic wetting and drying (XD3). For chlorides from seawater, it includes three levels: exposure to airborne salt but no direct seawater contact (XS1), permanent water immersion (XS2), and tidal, splash, and spray zones (XS3).

The freeze-thaw attack group comprises four levels: moderate water saturation without de-icing salts (XF1), moderate water saturation with de-icing salts (XF2), high water saturation without de-icing salts (XF3), and high water saturation with de-icing salts or seawater (XF4). The chemical attack group includes three levels: mild chemical attack (XA1), moderate chemical attack (XA2), and severe chemical attack (XA3). Classification within this group is based on the concentration of chemicals, such as SO42-, pH level, CO2, NH4+, Mg2+ in water environments, and total SO42- and acidity in soil environments.

It can be seen that this unified classification and grading of environments, though relatively simple, covers most environmental impacts on concrete and reinforced concrete. However, since the conditions for each level are described in general terms, assigning specific levels to local environments may vary significantly. Humidity values associated with conditions like dry, medium, etc., have not been clearly defined and may be interpreted differently. Some technical documents suggest that very dry environments correspond to humidity below 35%, which makes achieving the X0 condition in practice difficult. Currently, only a few countries designate X0 for indoor environments. Given Vietnam’s hot and humid climate with heavy rainfall, exposure conditions under normal circumstances are unlikely to be X0 and should be designated as XC1 to XC3. More detailed studies and analyses are needed to guide environmental classification based on specific construction components and local climate conditions in Vietnam.

For the remaining aggressive environments, due to Vietnam’s unique conditions, freeze-thaw environments are limited to freezing facilities, and chloride corrosion not from seawater mainly relates to certain industrial plants. The primary corrosive agent is chloride in marine environments. Here, the classification in TCVN 9346:2012 is quite similar to EN 206, although the marine atmospheric environment is more detailed in TCVN 9346:2012, with three zones: above water, shore areas within 1 km of the waterline, and nearshore areas 1 to 30 km from the waterline. According to TCVN 9346:2012, for each exposure environment, the concrete used must meet specific requirements regarding strength, impermeability, and materials, while reinforced concrete structures must ensure protective concrete cover thickness and limit crack width. In contrast, EN 206:2013+A2:2021 specifies maximum water-to-cement ratios, minimum strength grades, and minimum cement content. A comparison shows that TCVN 9346:2012 requires a higher minimum cement content but lower concrete strength compared to EN 206:2013+A2:2021. The protective concrete cover thickness and structural requirements are not specified in EN 206:2013+A2:2021 but are detailed in EN 1992-1-1:2004+A1:2014 [9]. According to these standards, the protective concrete cover thickness must ensure load transfer, protect reinforcement from corrosion, and provide fire resistance. The necessary protective cover thickness in corrosive environments depends on the structural classification, which is defined in national annexes. Therefore, replacing TCVN 9346:2012 would require the coordination of both technical concrete standards and structural design standards.

3. Requirement for Concrete

3.1. Use of Mineral Additives and k Conversion Factor

Concrete requirements include specifications for materials used, concrete composition, exposure environment classifications, and requirements for both concrete mixtures and the final concrete product. These requirements primarily reference technical standards, testing methods, and the application of various concepts. Notably, the use of mineral additives in concrete and the concept of equivalent performance stand out. When used in concrete, mineral additives (Type II) can improve properties like workability, resistance to segregation, and durability due to their filling effect and reactions such as pozzolanic or hydration reactions. The effect of mineral additives is accounted for in the binder ratio, which influences the water-to-binder ratio, strength, and durability.

Mineral additives are characterized by the k factor, representing the equivalent contribution to durability and strength compared to cement. Consequently, water-to-cement ratios and cement quantities can be applied as water-to-equivalent-cement ratios and equivalent cement quantities. The equivalent cement content is calculated as the sum of the cement quantity and the amount of cement substituted by the mineral additive.

EN 206:2013+A2:2021 recommends a k-factor of 0.4 when using fly ash according to EN 450-1:2012 [10] with CEM I and CEM II/A cements per EN 197-1:2011 [11], where the fly ash-to-cement ratio by mass does not exceed 0.33 and 0.25, respectively. A k-factor of 2.0 is recommended for silica fume per EN 13263-1:2005+A1:2009 [12], with the same types of cement, provided the silica fume-to-cement ratio by mass does not exceed 0.11 and the water-to-cement ratio is not more than 0.45 (and 1.0 for ratios above 0.45 in environments XC and XF). For ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBS) per EN 15167-1:2006 [13], the k-factor should be determined practically or by local regulations. Additionally, if the amount of additive used exceeds the recommended limits, the excess is not considered when calculating the equivalent cement content.

The concept of equivalent performance allows for adjustments in minimum cement content and maximum water-to-cement ratio when using mineral additives. This principle, along with the concept of equivalent binder performance, enables consideration of mineral additives in minimum cement content and water-to-cement ratio requirements.

Applying the cement substitution factor when using mineral additives accounts for their positive effects on concrete properties, leading to cement savings and enhancing the economic and technical performance of concrete. Local tests on available materials show that the cement substitution factor for some additives in Vietnam is higher than the standard values. This factor also depends on several variables, such as the replacement ratio, water-to-binder ratio, and concrete age. Even in Europe, the k-factor for fly ash ranges from 0.2 to 0.8, for silica fume from 1.0 to 2.0, and for GGBS from 0.4 to 1.0. However, the application of these concepts varies significantly across European countries [14]. Therefore, to successfully implement these concepts in Vietnam, existing research should be consolidated, and additional studies on local materials should be conducted to comprehensively evaluate this approach in the Vietnamese context.

3.2. Technical Requirements for Concrete Specifications

Technical requirements for concrete are divided into three categories: property-specified concrete, composition-specified concrete, and nominal composition concrete. Given the variability in concrete quality and the market-based approach among stakeholders, clear technical responsibilities must be assigned.

For property-specified concrete, the producer is responsible for ensuring the specified properties and any additional characteristics comply with the regulations. Basic property requirements include compressive strength, exposure class, the maximum and minimum sieve sizes for aggregate classification (d/D), and chloride content. Additional requirements for concrete mixtures and materials may be specified based on the standard’s guidelines. The producer must meet the concrete property requirements but is not bound by specific material quantities (except for cement content and water-to-cement ratio for durability requirements).

For composition-specified concrete, the producer is responsible for ensuring that the materials and concrete composition comply with the requirements. Technical requirements include the type and strength class of cement, target cement quantity, target water-to-cement ratio or workability, aggregate type and group, maximum chloride content in aggregates, and other specifications for lightweight or heavy aggregates, including bulk density, maximum grain size, and other limitations for aggregate composition, as well as the type and amount of chemical, mineral, or fiber additives (if any). The producer is not responsible for the properties of the concrete mixture or final product, and aggregate quantities are not specified.

Finally, nominal composition concrete refers to composition-specified concrete with a prescribed mix defined in technical documentation. Nominal composition concrete is only applicable to ordinary concrete of class no higher than C16/20 (or C20/25 if permitted) used for reinforced concrete structures in exposure classes X0 and XC1.

To support this concrete ordering approach, EN 206:2013+A2:2021 provides detailed information on the data the user must provide to the producer and the information the producer must send to the user, including necessary details on concrete delivery receipts. This information is crucial for quality control and resolving potential disputes between parties.

This method of specifying technical requirements differs significantly from how concrete is currently ordered in Vietnam. Although most concrete in Vietnam is specified according to technical requirements, the buyer usually monitors the concrete composition during mixing. This, along with acceptance based on concrete grade, reduces competition among producers with stable quality control. However, adopting the European concrete specification standards in Vietnam will face challenges related to management and payment issues. Guidelines for concrete norms and unit prices will need to be adjusted to align with these new concrete ordering methods.

4. Conformity Assessment

The conformity of concrete with specified requirements is assessed based on specific rules applicable to property-specified concrete, composition-specified concrete, and standardized prescribed concrete. Conformity testing for property-specified concrete is more complex and includes guidelines for compressive strength, flexural tensile strength, and non-strength properties. Conformity assessment for compressive strength as per EN 206:2013+A2:2021 is carried out on either individual or grouped concrete, applied during initial production or subsequent production phases. These are relatively new concepts in the construction practices of Vietnam.

Concrete groups are understood as sets of concrete components with reliable relationships in properties. This concept applies to normal and heavy concrete with compressive strength grades from C8/10 to C55/67, or lightweight concrete with strength grades from LC8/9 to LC55/60.

In the initial production phase, meaning the period until a minimum of 35 test results are obtained, compressive strength is considered compliant if it meets two criteria for individual strength values and average strength values (Method A):

fci ≥ fck - 4 (1)
fcm ≥ fck - 4 (2)

Where fci, fcm, fck are the individual strength value (strength of the sample batch), the average strength of 3 individual values, and the characteristic strength, respectively. It should be noted that when taking the average of 3 individual strength values, either the average of any 3 individual values (where one result can be used three times, i.e., overlapping) or the average of 3 consecutive individual values (no overlap) can be considered. However, the conformity criteria in this standard are based on non-overlapping averages, and it is recommended to follow this method in practice.

In subsequent phases, one can opt to use an assessment method based on standard deviation (Method B) or control charts (Method C). Control charts are recommended for relatively stable production conditions in factories and should be certified by a third party.

Method B can be applied to either individual concrete components or grouped concrete. When applied to a concrete group, it is necessary to first check whether each individual concrete component is suitable for inclusion in the group by comparing the unconverted average strength of each individual component with the group's conformity criteria. If a component is not suitable, it will be excluded and evaluated separately according to the initial production criteria (Method A, satisfying (1) and (2)).

For group members, a reference concrete should first be selected, and a correlation between the group’s concrete members and the reference concrete must be established to convert test results. The reference concrete can be chosen from either the most produced concrete or the concrete with a strength grade in the middle range of the group. The converted average strength of the concrete must meet the requirement:

fcm ≥ fck + 1,48 x σ (3)

Where σ is the standard deviation of the concrete family, which must be determined based on an analysis of at least 35 individual strength results within a 3-month period. The standard deviation is updated after each production phase. To continue applying this method, the standard deviation must fall within a recommended range specified in the standard. If it exceeds this range, a new standard deviation must be used for the next evaluation.

It is important to note that the coefficient 1.48 in equation (3) is not purely statistical. It reflects the principle of an average quality output limit, accounting for the probability of accepting values below the requirement and rejecting those above. Additionally, this coefficient takes into account the autocorrelation between samples based on the number of individual results [15, 16].

The application of Methods B and C in conformity testing provides a more realistic assessment of concrete quality by considering production variability. For highly stable production facilities, these methods allow for the acceptance of concrete with lower average strength than Method A, meaning production is more cost-effective and competitive. However, using these methods in practice requires the inspectors to have specialized knowledge and access to more detailed technical guidance on implementation procedures.

Currently, Method A is the most feasible approach for assessing concrete strength in Vietnam. However, sampling and data processing procedures differ significantly from those outlined in the existing TCVN 4453:1995 standard. The procedures in TCVN 10303:2014 share certain similarities by using statistical values and sample batch strength in assessments. However, due to various factors, TCVN 10303:2014 has yet to be widely implemented. Nevertheless, applying Method A for acceptance without using individual sample strength allows for concrete acceptance with lower average strength compared to TCVN 4453:1995. This helps reduce excessive strength margins, thus saving costs. However, it also raises challenges in improving quality control during production and construction.

5. Conclusion

Improving the system of construction standards and technical regulations is a timely and appropriate policy to address the existing issues within the current standard system. The drafting and promulgation of standards following a new approach should be strategically guided by core standards, which, in the field of concrete, have been identified as being based on the European standard system.

The technical requirements standard for concrete, harmonized with EN 206:2013+A2:2021, presents many advanced aspects compared to the current standards in Vietnam. This article has discussed several issues related to the classification of exposure environments, the use of mineral additives, specifying technical requirements for different types of concrete, and conformity assessment. Detailed analysis of the regulations and comparison with Vietnam's construction practices show that, in order to effectively implement the draft technical requirements standard for concrete under this new approach, further research and detailed guidelines need to be developed. These should address the designation of exposure environments suited to local conditions, guidelines for determining and applying the k-value concept (cement substitution factor) for mineral additives, guidelines for setting technical requirements for concrete, and guidelines for assessing concrete conformity.

Additionally, related legal documents on quality management harmonized with the European system, as well as guidelines for estimating concrete work budgets, are also crucial legal foundations that need to be drafted to ensure the successful application of this standard in Vietnam's construction practices.

Reference

1. TCVN 5574:1991, Kết cấu bê tông cốt thép - Tiêu chuẩn thiết kế.
2. TCVN 5574:2018, Thiết kế kết cấu bê tông và bê tông cốt thép.
3. TCVN 9346:2012, Kết cấu bê tông và bê tông cốt thép - Yêu cầu bảo vệ chống ăn mòn trong môi trường biển. 4. TCVN 12251:2018, Bảo vệ chống ăn mòn cho kết cấu xây dựng.
5. TCVN 4453:1995, Kết cấu bê tông và bê tông cốt thép toàn khối - Quy phạm thi công và nghiệm thu.
6. TCVN 9340:2012, Hỗn hợp bê tông trộn sẵn - Yêu cầu cơ bản đánh giá chất lượng và nghiệm thu.
7. TCVN 10303:2014, Bê tông - Kiểm tra và đánh giá cường độ chịu nén.
8. EN 206:2013+A2:2021, Concrete - Specification, performance, production and conformity.
9. EN 1992-1-1:2004+A1:2014, Design of concrete structures General rules and rules for buildings.
10. EN 450-1:2012, Fly ash for concrete - Part 1: Definition, specifications and conformity criteria. '
11. EN 197-1:2011, Cement - Part 1: Composition, specification and conformity criteria for common cements.
12. EN 13263-1:2005 +A1:2009, Silicafume for concrete - Part 1: Definitions, requirements and conformity criteria.
13. EN 15167-1:2006, Ground granulated blast furnace slag for use in concrete, mortar and grout - Part 1: Definitions, specifications and conformity criteria.
14. CEN/TR 16639, Use of k-value concept, equivalent concrete performance concept and equivalent performance of combinations concept.
15. Taerwe L., A General (1986), Basis for the Selection of Compliance Criteria, in International Association for Bridge and Structural Engineering Proceeding P102/86. p. 113-127.
16. Taerwe L. and Caspeele R. (2006). Conformity control of concrete: some basic aspects., in 4th International Probabilistic Symposium. p. 57-70.

Source: Journal of Science and Technology in Civil Engineering

News Related news

zalo
whatsapp
email
phone
Logo